Monthly Archives: March 2011

Massacre in Meydan: US 0 for 28 Saturday

While US bred/trained dirt horses remain unable to transfer that form to synthetics, Japan seems to have no such issues in running 1-2 in the $10 million Dubai World Cup. To be fair winner Victoire Pisa raced over turf in the Land of the Rising Sun, runner up Transcend was campaigned strictly over dirt – and both trained extensively on the unforgiving surface at home.

Don’t forget there were several turf races on the card Saturday as well, how did US runners fare when surface was eliminated from the equation? Not so good, as US turf horses made 10 starts and the best they could manage was a single 5th place finish.

Let’s step back and define what makes a ‘US’ horse. Is it the breeding? How about the conditioning? Of the 28 starts by US bred horses – only 2 places and 1 show were the result. Most notably one of those 2nd place finishes and the 3rd place finish were from horses bred in the US, but raced and conditioned in other countries. Without the effort of Bob Baffert’s Euroears in the 6F Golden Shaheen Sprint on Tapeta – strictly US born and trained horses would have been 0 for 15. Ouch.

Aidan O’Brien ran a strong 2nd with Master of Hounds, a US bred colt that undoubtedly has benefitted from training at Coolmore with the latest technology including heart rate and GPS monitoring:

This blog has well chronicled the difference in training styles between the US and other countries, for details see:

So, let’s stop arguing about surfaces for once – dirt, turf, and synthetics are all different in various ways, but a versatile horse can make the jump as evidenced this weekend by our Japanese friends. Of course we should also address the raceday drugs issue, of all the competitors in Dubai only the US allows such medication – and it doesn’t seem to do us any favors. Again, Well Armed and Curlin seemed just fine on dirt in the desert without the benefit of Lasix or Bute. Perhaps cheap horses need the help, but it’s an insult for our graded stakes winners to use the crutch of a syringe.

Noted druggie I Want Revenge disappointed greatly finishing 10th, while unable to “enjoy” the pre-race joint injections that have resulted in legal proceedings here in America:

Make no mistake, the US owns the dirt as evidenced by the triumphs of Curlin and Well Armed over previous runnings of the world’s richest horse race when it was held at Nad Al Sheba. All sports employ a home field advantage of some type, it’s only the best team and players that can overcome that adversity and unfamiliarity to win games and races. At least this weekend Japan made that transition in the thoroughbred world with great success, and I hope that gives the wonderful people of that country a brief respite from all of their troubles. Hats off to Sheikh Mo for graciously congratulating the winners with great enthusiasm in the face of a disappointing World Cup performance on his home course.

I love the US, and I feel we have the best bloodstock in the world. It will take some time, but eventually horsemanship will prevail, raceday drugs will be gone, and we will condition our horses for more than 15 minutes a day – or will I be writing this same piece again after Dubai World Cup 2021?


Uncle Mo, Comma to the Top, and the Great Wall of China. What?

“When asked, “How do you write?” I invariably answer, “One word at a time,” and the answer is invariably dismissed. It sounds too simple to be true, but consider the Great Wall of China, if you will: one stone at a time, man. But I’ve read you can see that mother****** from space without a telescope.”
— Stephen King

That is what thoroughbred conditioning is to me: building an equine Great Wall one stone at a time. A stone is a breeze or race that results in the horse coming back days later stronger, fitter, and sounder. Doesn’t seem like much, a breeze every 6 days, 12 races a season (ideally) – but boy, oh boy can the results add up to something significant as most former Triple Crown champs followed a similar course back in the old days.

One key, of course, is not to drop any of these stones on your foot, because then it’s either off to the farm – or off to the pharmacy and a career filled with multiple injections and stall time designed to simply survive to the next race. See Revenge, I Want.

So, one has to be careful or aggressive, and often the decision is an economic one. It’s much easier to drill on a big sound colt in your backyard who you bought for $20k than it is to drill on a $200k purchase for a deep pocketed owner with the whole world watching.

Where am I going with this? To two descendants of Indian Charlie on the 2011 Derby trail: Comma To the Top and Uncle Mo. Two trainers, Peter Miller and Todd Pletcher. Two owners, a relatively unknown Hollywood partnership and Mike Repole (who I really like, by the way) – he’s no IEAH or David Lanzman.

Interestingly enough, Comma To the Top is gelded – so no stallion career here, we may see this gem race 50 times by age 5. I suspect no one endeavoring to develop a stallion prospect would race 10 times at 2, and breeze 6F in January of a 3yo campaign, this isn’t 1930.

Pedigree, Shmedigree.

Here we have the genetics of Indian Charlie in two colts – so ideally we have a fairly similar starting point. Regular readers know I put little emphasis on breeding: genetics simply set the blueprint for what is possible – but conditioning/racing dictates how much of that blueprint is developed, or squandered.

Let’s take just one simple measurable (at autopsy) physiological trait: the number and function of mitochondria in muscles. Mitochondria are the energy powerhouses that take oxygen from the blood and transfer it into muscular energy which propels a horse down the track.

Genetics may dictate a colt is born with 20 of these things in a particular muscle, but appropriate physical conditioning increases this number, if done correctly. The more you ask the equine body to produce mitochondria – they more it gives you. The more it gives you, the greater your ‘cruising speed’ as Todd Pletcher astutely calls it. I define this as V200 – how fast you can travel when your oxygen carrying system is maxed out and you must tap into that 3-4F of anaerobic burst most thoroughbreds possess.

And you aren’t asking for much development when breezing a short 4F every 10 days and only racing 2-3 times in your 2 year old year. You are playing it safe to avoid injury and maximize residual value should you capture your black type.

When it comes time to physical conditioning the paths of Comma To the Top and Uncle Mo diverge very quickly. Who has developed more mitochondria since birth and therefore possesses more stamina at this moment in time? Let’s enumerate the training/racing schedules of each:

Uncle Mo – No DRF recorded workouts for this one. But Pletcher says he should get his first 3F move since last November’s Breeders Cup victory at Palm Meadows this upcoming week.

Horse Name Date Track Dist Time Surf Cond. B/H  
Comma to the Top 01/25/2011 HOL 6F 1:10.40 All Weather Track Fast H  
01/19/2011 HOL 6F 1:14.80 All Weather Track Fast H  
01/13/2011 HOL 5F :59.80 All Weather Track Fast B  
01/07/2011 HOL 4F :48.40 All Weather Track Fast B  
12/12/2010 HOL 5F :59.40 All Weather Track Fast H  
12/06/2010 HOL 4F :48.20 All Weather Track Fast H  
11/21/2010 HOL 5F :59.40 All Weather Track Fast H  
11/15/2010 HOL 4F :48.40 All Weather Track Fast H  
11/01/2010 HOL 4F :47.40 All Weather Track Fast H  

Career race results:

Uncle Mo – Race Results & Past Performances

[Add Race Result][Add Horse]

11/06/10 1st CD 7 1 1/16 m D Breeders’ Cup Juvenile-G1 Uncle Mo 1:42.60
10/09/10 1st Bel 9 1 mile D Champagne-G1 Uncle Mo 1:34.51
08/28/10 1st Sar 5 6 f D MSW Uncle Mo 1:09.21



Comma To The Top – Race Results & Past Performances

[Add Race Result][Add Horse]

12/18/10 1st Hol 9 1 1/16 m S CashCall Futurity-G1 Comma To The Top 1:44.72
11/27/10 1st Hol 7 1 mile T Generous-G3 Comma To The Top 1:34.77
11/06/10 1st Hol 9 1 1/16 m S Real Quiet Comma To The Top 1:43.56
09/08/10 6th Dmr 8 7 f S Del Mar Futurity-G1 J P’s Gusto 1:22.95
08/08/10 4th Dmr 8 6 1/2 f S Best Pal-G2 J P’s Gusto 1:16.61
07/22/10 1st Dmr 6 5 1/2 f S Mcl Comma To The Top 1:03.67
06/12/10 6th Hol 10 5 f D MSW Western Mood 0:58.02
05/20/10 2nd Hol 8 4 1/2 f D Mcl The Great Caper 0:52.52


Race info courtesy of Horse Racing Nation.

Comma To the Top also had 3 earlier races not reflected here, they were claiming class also – one of us could now own a Derby prospect with $500k+ in earnings for the princely sum of $30k or so, what a great sport this is!-

Where do I get this equine Great Wall metaphor from? Here is a graph from an equine science journal out of Cambridge, Mass:

Training load is a breeze/race and the x-axis is elapsed time in days. You see, after a piece of work and the resulting fatigue, there is a period of Overcompensation where the systems of the body make positive adaptations in order to make successive training loads easier to achieve. More mitochondria being one such change. But, if you wait too long before adding another Training Load, you lose the overcompensation effect – and the benefits of cumulative fitness, as seen below in graphical form:

Uncle Mo is line A – few and widely spaced works/breezes  resulting in less than optimal fitness development over time.

Comma To the Top is line B – more races, more works, more closely spaced together in an effort to capitalize on the concept of Overcompensation.

Line C is what happens if you breeze/race too much, too often and breakdown occurs – not too common these days – referred to as ‘overtraining’ by most in the industry.

Both have 2 year old experience on dirt, which Nunamaker at New Bolton has proven is best for building strong bones, ligaments, and tendons. I suspect that Comma has many more breezes over this surface during his formative years, however, that does Uncle Mo.

Now Uncle Mo seems destined to a dirt prep season (which I recommend) – and so far Comma is back to synthetics at Hollywood. I hope the connections see fit to try him on dirt again before the Derby (Santa Anita perhaps), or at least train on the dirt loop at Hollywood in order to maximize neuromuscular coordination on that surface going into Churchill.

My two cents: a 50% chance that Uncle Mo will get injured during his prep for the Derby. If he does survive unscathed, Pletcher will lose a few others in his place. He’ll only breeze 4-6F a few times, he’ll only race twice – and I think he comes up lame in the process. I hope not, but that is what I forsee.

I can’t blame Pletcher, with his 2yo exploits, Mo seems like a fantastic specimen that I would be afraid to drill on too much also. Baffert, Lukas, Assmussen, and Pletcher himself win big races with such a prep schedule every year anyway, so they have no reason to change after listening to a nobody like myself.

However, I will be pulling hard for Comma To the Top as his campaign to this point clearly illustrates the one advantage the little guy has over the big operations: conditioning – you can spend more time and effort on each one when you don’t have 200 prospects spread out over 4 strings nationwide. It doesn’t cost one additional dime to train in this manner, simply takes the will and the effort to stand out from the crowd.

With his foundation of race specific works and races, he has the mettle to enter and be competitive at all three classics, while no other lightly trained horse could even run in all three last year. Look for him to be breezing miles in April while most others are still working 4F.

Say Comma To the Top pulls of a Mine that Bird type spring and fall – will trainers then emulate his aggressive prep program, or stay with the Pletcher model?

Traditional horsemanship has pegged Uncle Mo as worth 10x that of Comma To the Top as evidenced by the auction results. Will that stand up throughout the 2011 racing season?

So many questions, and so many answers to follow. I love horseracing.

(Please excuse this repost in early March, when I moved my blog the earlier post somehow disappeared, this was written before Comma debuted in 2011 and before Mo even breezed at Palm Meadows)